A 2021 LDV Deliver 9 diesel minibus arrived this week with the vehicle in limp mode, and diagnosis pointing to a failed High Pressure Exhaust Gas Recirculation (HP EGR) valve.

The owner had already approached their local LDV dealership on the Sunshine Coast for a repair quotation. The quote they received was $6,002.00 for parts and labour, with the dealership estimating approximately 15 hours to complete the work.

Before committing to that expense, the owner decided to get a second opinion.

Two EGR valves, two different jobs

Modern diesel engines use Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) systems to help reduce harmful nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions. By redirecting a controlled amount of exhaust gas back into the engine’s intake system, combustion temperatures are reduced, helping limit NOx production.

The LDV Deliver 9 diesel engine uses two EGR systems:

  • High Pressure EGR: Takes exhaust gas from the exhaust manifold before the turbocharger and directs it back into the intake system. This system is particularly important under certain operating conditions and helps control emissions.
  • Low Pressure EGR: Takes exhaust gas further downstream in the exhaust system, after the emissions treatment equipment, and returns it to the intake ahead of the turbocharger.

In this case, it was the High Pressure EGR valve that had failed. The resulting fault caused the engine management system to put the vehicle into limp mode, restricting performance to protect the engine and emissions system.

The HP EGR valve needed replacing, but accessing it was going to be a substantial job.

Not your average EGR replacement

Some EGR replacements are relatively straightforward. This one certainly wasn’t.

The High Pressure EGR valve on the Deliver 9 is buried deep within the engine compartment, with significant dismantling required to reach it. Much of the work had to be carried out from underneath the vehicle while it was raised on our workshop hoist.

This was not a case of simply opening the bonnet and removing a few components.

To gain access, our mechanics had to remove the windscreen wipers and cowl, engine covers, heat shields, intercooler and all intake components. Wiring, coolant lines and exhaust pipes also had to be disconnected.

The job became considerably more involved when it was necessary to support the engine, remove the crossmember and engine mount, and remove the oil cooler to gain access to the failed EGR valve.

Once the valve was accessible, the mating surfaces were cleaned and the replacement unit installed.

The entire assembly then had to be carefully put back together, including all associated wiring, coolant connections, exhaust pipes, intake components and engine mountings.

The cooling system was refilled and bled, fault codes cleared and the new EGR valve’s operation checked.

Finally, the vehicle was road tested, inspected on the hoist for leaks and checked again to confirm everything was operating correctly.

The numbers tell an interesting story

This is where the owner’s decision to seek a second opinion really paid off.

The local LDV dealership had quoted $6,002 for the repair, estimating 15 hours of labour.

Autosavvy Mechanical quoted $2,636, and our mechanics successfully completed the work in just 8 hours.

LDV Dealer Autosavvy Mechanical
Quoted repair cost $6,002 $2,636
Estimated/actual labour time 15 hours quoted 8 hours actual
Difference in price $3,366 saved

The value of a second opinion

We understand that vehicle owners want their vehicles repaired properly, but they also want confidence that they are paying a fair price.

This job is a good example of why it can be worthwhile getting another professional opinion before committing to a major repair.

Complex modern diesel engines require experience, the right diagnostic equipment and the willingness to tackle difficult jobs. At Autosavvy Mechanical, we don’t shy away from challenging repairs.

Whether it’s an LDV, European vehicle, 4WD or everyday family car, our focus is the same: accurate diagnosis, quality workmanship and fair, competitive pricing.

Before agreeing to an expensive repair, talk to Autosavvy Mechanical. A second opinion could save you thousands.

Autosavvy Mechanical – Noosaville
Professional mechanical servicing, diagnostics and repairs.

 

by Jeremy Bycroft

Share

Leave A Comment

Related Posts